Our 2024 Premium Choice Cat Litter Reviews And Coupons

Having trouble picking a kitty litter for your furry friends? There are hundreds, if not thousands, of different brands of cat litter on the market – and with different formulas, prices, features and benefits, it can be hard to know which one may be right for you.

35% Off at Chewy.com

+ Free Shipping

Save Now

You want a cat litter that’s going to be absorbent, keep your home clean, and keep your precious cats happy, and depending on the age and health of your cats, you may need to pick a litter that’s formulated just for them. Kittens, for example, should not use clumping litter, since it can be a choking hazard.

So what’s the right cat litter for you? How can you make sure you get a high-quality product without overpaying? By reading this article, of course! We’ve taken it upon ourselves to review cat litters from all of the major brands, and in this piece, we’ll be discussing Premium Choice Cat Litter, and reviewing their line of products.

Premium Choice Cat Litter is produced by the brand Minerals Technologies, and is a relatively new product. One of the unique things about Premium Choice Cat Litter is that it’s exclusively sold online and through independent, local pet stores and other retailers – you can’t find it in your everyday big-box store like WalMart, or your local grocery store, in most cases.

Because of this, Premium Choice Cat Litter is known for delivering great performance at a reasonable price, particularly if you buy in bulk and choose a 50-lb bag of cat litter. In addition, the company is known for handling every part of the production process on their own – from mining the clay and other materials for the litter, to converting it into a usable product, packaging it, and selling it. You can shop with confidence, knowing that every step of the process was handled responsibly, without any third parties.

Let’s dig into the details now, and discuss everything that you need to know about Premium Choice Cat Litter in 2024. We’ll discuss price, absorptive power, tracking, and plenty of other topics, so that you can find out if this product is right for you – or if you’d be better off with another brand of cat litter.

What Are The Different Types Of Premium Choice Cat Litters?

Wondering what your product options are with Premium Choice? The company has a wide variety of different products, including scented, unscented, extra strength, and products with baking soda. Let’s take a deeper look at each individual type of cat litter now, so that you can see which one may be right for your needs.

Premium Choice Carefree Kitty Unscented Solid Scoop Cat Litter

This is the “flagship” product of Premium Choice, and its most popular type of cat litter. The Premium Choice Carefree Kitty Unscented Solid Scoop Cat Litter has great reviews both on retailers like Chewy, and on a number of other third-party review websites.

It’s been formulated to be completely scent-free, which is a good thing if you and your cats don’t like fragrances, and prefer a scentless, odor-absorbing product. If your cat is very sensitive to fragrances, and often refuses to use litter that’s scented, this product will definitely be a good choice for you – and help you deal with the inconvenience of your cat avoiding the litter box.

In addition, there are no other chemical additives in the product. It’s made completely out of natural materials – clay and sodium bentonite. There are no other ingredients, so you and your cats can relax, and know that you’re enjoying a totally natural, responsibly-sourced product.

This specific litter has been designed to work well with multiple-cat households, with strong clumping power and a low-tracking formula, though some customers online have noted that it is slightly dustier than comparable cat litters – possibly because it has no chemical additives to reduce dust buildup. Despite that, though, this is definitely a good choice if you and your cat are sensitive to strong scents.

Premium Choice Carefree Kitty Unscented Extra Strength with Baking Soda Solid Scoop Cat Litter

If you have more than one or two cats, this is the Premium Choice product that you’re going to be interested in. It’s been formulated with maximum strength, clumping, and absorptive power, to help you manage a multiple-cat household, and multiple litter boxes.

It’s also been formulated for minimal tracking, even if you have quite a few cats. A unique, pyramidal granule shape is used in this product, which helps prevent it from getting stuck in your cat’s paws and claws, and prevents scatter and tracking.

Additionally, this product is completely natural and free of any fragrances or chemicals. It’s composed only of high-quality clay and sodium bentonite, as well as sodium bicarbonate (baking soda).

The baking soda helps boost its odor-absorbing power even further, without any harmful fragrances that could prevent your cat from using the litter box. The product itself has absolutely no smell, and even when it’s heavily soiled, the absorbency of the clay and the baking soda helps lock in the scent of urine and pet waste, preventing it from reaching the rest of your home.

Premium Choice Carefree Kitty Dual Odor Eliminator Cat Litter

If you have problems with scent control in your home, this Premium Choice product may be right for you. Unlike the previous two products from Premium Choice, it’s scented, which means that it’s not right for cats that are very sensitive to smells – but it’s ideal if you have a lot of cats, and have difficulties controlling the smell of feces and urine in your litter box.

This product is designed with a unique, two-phase odor elimination technology that starts controlling odors as soon as your cat uses the litter box. The scents are trapped within the litter and absorbed, while the waste is desiccated and dried out as quickly as possible, to prevent the scent from spreading. Additionally, the fresh scent of the litter helps to cover up any nasty smells in the rooms where your litter boxes are.

Despite the addition of fragrances and odor eliminators, this is still a natural product, too. The primary ingredients remain the same as the previous two products we looked at – sodium bentonite and high-quality clay.

Premium Choice Carefree Kitty Fresh Scent with Baking Soda Solid Scoop Cat Litter

For those who have multiple cats and struggle with strong scents from pet waste, this product from Premium Choice combines the original Premium Choice formula with both baking soda and a Fresh Scent fragrance. Even in the most demanding environments, this cat litter can last up to 30 days with regular cleaning and waste removal, ensuring a healthy, odor-free environment for you and your cats.

With the combined power of the fragrance and baking soda, odors and nasty smells are absorbed and covered up, keeping your home more clean, comfortable, and cat-friendly. Like the other Premium Choice products on this list, this cat litter is made with clay and sodium bentonite, and manufactured with a pyramid shape to reduce tracking and dust by your cats, and enhance its clumping potential.

Premium Choice Cat Litter Coupons

Interested in trying out one of these cat litters from Premium Choice? Looking to save some money, and find coupons? Unfortunately, you won’t find any manufacturers coupons for Premium Choice Cat Litter online – they simply don’t exist.

However, that doesn’t mean that you can’t find a way to save a bunch of money on cat litter. Your best bet for savings is to head to Chewy.com. This online retailer has the full lineup of Premium Choice Carefree Kitty cat litter products for sale at the lowest prices online.

Not only that, but you can get big savings with coupon codes, special sales, product recommendations, and discounts – such as 30% off when you sign up for AutoShip, and free shipping on all orders over $49, which is a huge savings when shopping for a 50-lb bag of cat litter!

35% Off at Chewy.com

+ Free Shipping

Save Now

If you’re ready to pick out one of these cat litter products, you can start shopping now, and have it delivered to your door in just a few business days – making your shopping experience fun and convenient.

Still not sure which type of litter may be right for you, or if you’re interested in Premium Choice Cat Litter? Keep reading, and we’ll discuss the products offered by this brand in further detail. We’ll break down price comparisons, absorptive power, odor control, dust-friendliness, and every other aspect of this product, so that you can make sure it’s right for you and your fuzzy friends. We’ll also answer some of the most common FAQS about Premium Choice Cat Litter. Let’s get started now!

Premium Choice Cat Litter Review


Depending on the product you choose, you can expect to pay about 2x more per pound for Premium Choice than you would for a “value” brand like Tidy Cats. This depends on your product, however – products like Premium Choice Carefree Kitty Fresh Scent with Baking Soda are more expensive than the original Premium Choice Carefree Kitty Unscented Solid Scoop Cat Litter, because there are more additives, and the formulation of the litter is more complex.

However, the price of Premium Choice Cat Litter is about the same as most other natural, clay-based cat litters. You won’t pay a huge price premium compared to a competing product like Dr. Elsey’s, for example – they’re usually around the same price per pound.

While there are many folks in who have reviewed the product and noted its higher price, most of them have noted that it’s worth the premium, noting that it’s “Easy to scoop out,” and saying that “tracks less than other litters, the price is right, and it scoops well.”

If you’re looking for a completely natural product with a high-quality formulation, it’s hard to beat Premium Choice Cat Litter, even though it costs a little more than litter from “the other guys.”


All Premium Choice Cat Litter products are made with high-quality clay and sodium bentonite, which is the “gold-standard” for natural, clay-based cat litter. These products react quickly to both urine and feces, clumping up within seconds and removing moisture to help control scent. This provides superior clumping and absorption, without the use of silica gels or other artificial compounds.

In addition, customers have noted that this brand of litter tends to form smaller, durable clumps that do not break apart when scooped, which makes it easier to dispose of cat urine and feces without contacting it directly. This makes it easier to clean the litter box, and ensure that you remove all waste, so that your cats have a safe, healthy environment in which to do their business.

Odor Control

The amount of odor control offered by Premium Choice Cat Litters depends on the product you choose. The unscented products offer reasonably good odor control without any fragrance, as long as you clean the litter box regularly.

For more odor control, we’d recommend purchasing a Premium Choice Cat Litter with baking soda. Baking soda really helps improve odor control, and it’s completely scentless, natural, and organic, so you do not have to worry about any strong fragrances which could irritate your cat.

On the other hand, if your cat is not sensitive to scented litter, purchasing a product like Premium Choice Carefree Kitty Fresh Scent with Baking Soda may allow you even better odor control. The clay, bentonite and baking soda absorb smells, while the natural Fresh Scent helps cover up any remaining odor – making it great if you have a lot of cats.


Tracking of kitty litter – when cats get litter stuck in their paws and claws and spread it throughout your home – can be a huge issue, especially if you have multiple cats, or a smaller home and need to have litter boxes in areas with heavy people traffic.

Premium Choice Cat Litters are one of the best products when it comes to tracking. It clumps easily and does not break apart, and the pyramidal shape is less prone to getting stuck in your cat’s paws, which means less litter tracked throughout your home. Multiple reviewers online have noted that it “Doesn’t track everywhere,” “tracks less than other litters” and that they “notice very little coming out of the box,” after the cats use the litter box.


Dust can be a big problem when it comes to cat litter. It can spread throughout your home, and even carry parasites and bacteria from pet waste, so you want to choose a product that has minimal dust to ensure that you and your cats stay healthy.

Premium Choice Cat Litters are made with a low-dust formulation, designed to ensure that microparticles of dust are not released into the air and do not settle elsewhere in your home. This helps keep your home clean, safe, and free of unsightly and dangerous litter dust.


Premium Choice Cat Litters are made out of natural clay and sodium bentonite, which react strongly to the presence of moisture by clumping. That means that if you try to flush these products, the cat litter will clump together in your pipes, eventually resulting in a blockage – and an extremely expensive plumbing repair bill. Do not try to flush any of these products, or you risk damaging your plumbing.


While sodium bentonite and clay are both naturally-occurring substances and are eco-friendly materials that do not require processing with harmful chemicals, they must often be strip-mined, which can be harmful to the environment, so this product is not the best choice if you are looking for an eco-friendly material.

FAQs Regarding Premium Choice Cat Litters

You’ve got questions about Premium Choice Cat Litters, and we’ve got answers. Let’s take a look at a few FAQs about these products now, and answer the most common questions that customers have when shopping for cat litter.

  • Are Premium Choice Cat Litters Biodegradable? No. Clay and sodium bentonite are naturally-occurring, inorganic materials. This means that Premium Choice Cat Litter will not biodegrade. It will have to be treated in a landfill. However, clay and sodium bentonite are not harmful, and are a natural part of the soil. So while this material is not biodegradable, it won’t have a negative effect on the landfill environment.
  • Do Premium Choice Cat Litters Come In Resealable Bags? Yes. All Premium Choice Cat Litters come in resealable bags, which makes it easier for you to keep your home clean, and store the products. In addition, some products, like the Premium Choice Carefree Kitty Unscented Solid Scoop Cat Litter 16-lb container, come in a hard-sided plastic container, which may make it easier for some folks to carry, scoop, and handle.
  • Do Premium Choice Cat Litters Contain Silica? No. As a clay and bentonite-based cat litter, Premium Choice Cat Litters contain absolutely no silica, making it a 100% natural product.
  • Is Premium Choice Cat Litter Kitten Friendly? No. Premium Choice Cat Litter should not be used for kittens under 2-3 months of age, because every Premium Choice product uses a clumping formulation. This is dangerous to kittens, who are unfamiliar with litter boxes, and could ingest clumps of litter. We recommend using an alternative, non-clumping litter until your kittens are at least 3 months old, and familiar with the litter box.


While it may cost more compared to some other non-clay products, the 100% all-natural formulation of Premium Choice Cat Litter makes it a great choice if you’d like to avoid silica and other such chemicals, and rely on a clay-based litter. In addition, with truly fragrance-free options available, this litter is ideal for cats who are extremely sensitive to smells. It also results in minimal tracking and litter spread, and has a dust-free formulation which helps keep your home and environment cleaner and healthier – as well as powerful clumping that keeps pet waste contained.

If you’re interested in trying out Premium Choice Cat Litter for yourself, just head over to Chewy.com now, and take a look at its selection of Premium Choice Products. You’re sure to find a great deal, and with fast free shipping, you can get your litter delivered straight to your door.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *